Yesterday I got to spend the day in sunny Springfield, MA at the New England Museums Association 2010 Annual conference. I was there to give a half-day workshop on interpretive writing with Cindy Cullen, which was a great learning experience in and of itself. There’s nothing like trying to explain what you know to crystallize your thinking. It was interesting how often the discussion moved from writing to content strategy, since writing is just the last, most visible expression of a much longer, more involved process of figuring out what to do in an exhibition. More on that later…
After the workshop, I was standing around chatting with three former colleagues when of the Executive Director of NEMA came up to us and said, “What are you guys doing in five minutes?” There was the pregnant silence that usually follows an obvious setup question. Finally we all mumbled, “Nothing…” and he brightened and asked us if we’d be willing to fill in for the speaker for their career conversations session, who hadn’t made it to the conference. Strangely enough, I was only there because the original presenter of the writing workshop had canceled two weeks before the conference and Cindy and I had volunteered to fill in. I guess it was my day to helpful. We all agreed and were hustled into a room with a dozen or so attendees, most of whom were trying to start their museum careers, and off we went.
I had no idea what the event was supposed to be, other than a chance for those of us in the profession to share whatever wisdom (?) we had with emerging museum professionals. It was a smallish group, maybe twenty people total. Most of them were at that terrifying stage of life where they’d decided what they wanted to be, but hadn’t yet figured out how to break in. And being intelligent folks, they knew that chances were good that many of them wouldn’t even get the chance to start a museum career. And then there was us, the replacement speakers, two of whom had been laid off in the middle of promising careers, one who’d retired and gone into business, and me, still plugging away at the same institution where I’d first discovered the joy of museums when I was a kid. Sounds like recipe for disaster, doesn’t it? Or at least for a really bleak talk. But it wasn’t. It was a hard discussion at times, especially when people were sharing their pain, but it was exactly the kind of discussion the field needs to have.
Listening to the stories of the presenters, it was interesting to hear the similarities. Every one of us could list the entry-level jobs we’d toiled at when we were starting out, and the meandering paths we took before we’d found our identities as “museum people”. We were all very much shaped by the need to acquire the skills we eventually accumulated and you can see it in our career paths. The rising generation of museum people already get a grounding in all these skills as part of any museum studies program.
For their part, the people trying to start their careers could all rattle off the same litany of obstacles they’d encountered – no way to differentiate themselves, dead-end internships, or worse, long-term volunteer or “intern” positions that seem like sleazy ways to get labor for free from people. And the steady pressure of next year’s crop of museum studies graduates coming into the job market, ready to work more for less to get their foot in the door. I will confess that I have been known to disparage museum studies programs for how well they do (or don’t) prepare students to actually work in museums, but I will say this. I only have the deepest admiration people trying to get into museum work in this dismal economic climate. My hats off to you and good luck! These truly are tough times.
So what could we share?
I was a bit scared we wouldn’t have any useful advice to give. The museum profession looked very different in the 1970s and 80s, before museum studies programs existed. It turned out that we did find some useful things to say.
Personal contact is priceless.
I owe my career to the fact that I able to hound my eventual boss and mentor from my perch at the Information Desk at the Museum. She owed her start to friends of friends. And others could provide similar stories. We were somebody, not just a name or a resume. If anything, personal knowledge counts for even more now than it did in decades past. I can advertise for an intern position and be guaranteed to get a stack (literally) of resumes of people who all possess impeccable credentials and who are probably overqualified. So how am I supposed to decide whom to interview? It’s not easy, but I know that if any of them were known to me or passed along by colleagues, they’d go right into the pile of applicants to consider.
Look for potential mentors, don’t just hope they find you
The session was one of those kinds of intense conversations that kept right on going after the session was over. One situation that came up twice in a row was a newcomer expressing an interest in a particular kind of museum work and the established people saying, “Well, if you’re interested in ______, you should go introduce yourself to ______.” This feeds back in to my first point about personal contact, but it’s more than just that. The field is small enough that you can really find out who’s doing interesting work. Liked that exhibition? Find out who curated it. Does Museum X have a great website? Find out who does their web design. Regardless of your particular area of interest in museums, if you poll a group of twenty established professionals about who they think are the top ten people in their discipline, you’ll be certain to A) have an interesting conversation about the state of the field, and B) hear a few names many times.
Don’t focus your search too narrowly
One young woman spoke very movingly about her quest to break into exhibit graphic design and supporting herself by doing web design and Flash programming. My advice to her was not look at job posting by department, but instead look at jobs she was qualified for, regardless of whether they in design departments. At my museum, interactive exhibits are made by one department, computer-based interactives by another. I know museums where their web developers work in the Marketing department, and places where they work for Education. Museum org charts are very… unique… and it’s better, I think, to find a first job that matches your skills than to wait til you find an open position in the area you want.
Go to conferences, and don’t hang out with friends.
Obviously, this was preaching to the choir, but it can’t be overstated, I think. Even a regional conference like NEMA brings together lots of interesting, committed professionals who are open to new experiences and new people. The grumps tend to stay at work and mutter about what a waste of time conferences are, so there’s little to fear. Many museum conferences offer student rates, scholarships, and opportunities to trade your labor for admission to the conference. It’s a great way to network, and put faces to names you may have heard. And it’s a way to act on the three points above in one fell swoop. With the proliferation of Emerging Professionals special interest groups, you never have to worry about being completely alone with a thousand strangers. When I was at the AAM/NAME Creativity and Collaboration Workshop a couple of years ago, I made a solemn vow I’d eat with different people for every meal, and it was one of the best decisions I made.
POSTSCRIPT: The Universe is often none-too-subtle. Just in case I hadn’t gotten the hint that getting out of the office and engaging more is good for the soul, I got a third reminder at lunch time, when a colleague came in to the office and said, “Ed, I’ve got a bunch of university students who are looking at career paths. Could you come talk to them for 30 seconds about what it skills you need to go into exhibit development? It’ll be quick, I promise! Please?”
“Sure, I’d be happy to.”
Nice post Ed, and all true. I’d add that often the smaller conferences are better than large ones for emerging professionals as it is easier to meet people (and run into again and again) and to have deeper conversations. AAM or ASTC can be overwhelming, and some of the really meaty conversations there happen in places it is hard for relatively new folk to break into.
Yeah, I agree. I still remember the my first conference (AAM), tagging along as Jan Crocker’s new assistant. I felt completely out of my depth and flabbergasted that she seemed to know everybody and everybody knew her. I couldn’t imagine how you could possibly get to know that many people.
I also was tapped to speak at the session on careers in museums. Ed has given me an opportunity to say here something I wish I had said at the session. That is, it is the journey that makes your career. It seemed as if the museum studies students who were is the session were in pursuit of the ideal job. My belief is that the ideal job can be the one you are in because it is the opportunity to learn that which prepares you for the next job or next direction in life. One can’t be afraid to embrace the journey. It’s where the best learning occurs.
The inimitable Nina Simon of Museum 2.0 weighs in with her own story of how she got where she is now (total rock star and thinker) and some thoughts on getting ahead in this crazy field. Definitely worth a read.
Thank you for this post! I found it via Nina Simon’s site and am always glad to have another interesting blog to follow. As an emerging museum professional I am always looking for tips and hints on how to worm into the field. Having recently attended the Mid-Atlantic Association of Museums Conference, I know young professionals are exceedingly grateful for the networking opportunities and are thankful to seasoned professionals, like yourself, who are willing to guide us.
(Pam Schwartz blogs at http://madamuseo.wordpress.com )
Thanks, Pam. I’m glad you found your way here. Nina’s post was fascinating to read for me, since our career trajectories have been so different. My path has been under one (very large) roof, and hers has taken her all over the country, to institutions large and small. There is no one right way to build a career.
The Virginia Association of Museums now offers a free PDF download of their first white paper, “Museum Careers: Fit, Readiness & Development.” . Don’t have time to look at it now, but somebody should, and report back!
I just read the “Museum Careers: Fit, Readiness & Development” white paper by the VAM. I think it is a miniature version of “What Color is your Parachute” because it is literally a survey to help you analyze if you should work at museums, the position and the size. It would it is probably helpful for an undergraduate or someone really drastically changing their careers and having no real knowledge of how a museum works. I did it (though I have already worked in museums) and my results indicated I do have the personality traits and interests to work at museum, probably in Curatorial and for a small museum. Coincidentally, this was exactly what I did! However, I am not that because I was thinking of my past experiences, it affected my answers and produced my own history.
I actually left the museum world in NY to go back to get my PhD. I have both a BA & MA in Art History, but wanted to be able to produce amazing scholarship to go with my abilities as a curator and grant-writer. I am planning on emailing this to our Career Services person because I think it might be something a little extra helpful for young students thinking about museums. However, NO ONE should use this as a career determiner, but it can be useful.
That’s my opinion!
I’m stumbling upon this blog post several months later, but that “… young woman [who] spoke very movingly about her quest to break into exhibit graphic design and supporting herself by doing web design and Flash programming” is me! I didn’t realize that I’d left an impression on you and wish I was following your blog when you’d written this post!
I’m hoping to attend your next meet-up, so hopefully we can catch up then. Currently I’m interning, in the process of launching a new website for a new freelancing business (graphic design, exhibit design, and artifact photography), and not programming Flash anymore. 🙂 Still chipping away at the “breaking into museums” wall, but I’m not as downtrodden as I may have come across at the NEMA conference. It’s still tough, no doubt, but I have more optimism about it now!
Hope to talk to you soon. Thank you so much for stepping in at the last minute for that talk, it has really left an impression on me, months later.
I’m so glad to hear you’re still at it! I think everybody at that session got something to think about, emerging, and emerged. It was a pretty powerful experience. I’m glad NEMA offered it.
We’ll have to catch up at the next meetup, which you’re reminded me that I should really finalize a date and place for. 😉
Hi Ed, great! The dates suggested in the comments of that post work for me, too, so I will patiently wait for a location to be secured. 🙂
It was definitely a great session, I learned so much, and have heard it will be back this coming conference. I’m hoping to attend the entire conference this year, and maybe get in on that pecha kucha (whatever …) if I can swing a Tuesday night.
See you soon!
Comments are closed.